I feel like he’d be a terrible gift giver for a while because he has no practice with it and no worthwhile social skills. So for a while he’s gonna have to ask the others for advice ((and at least he’s smart enough to not ask Nicky for help. Matt’s a safer bet in this case.)) He looks for small, practical things, like lotion to keep Allison’s hands soft or tea for Renee or funky shot glasses for Nicky, things like that. By the time all the kids come along he realizes online wishlists are godsends and just uses those.